Shiny Chandravel, Assistant Opinions & Humor Editor
Benjamin Harrison was the 23rd president of the United States of America. He was not elected by the American people.
George W. Bush was the 43rd president. He was not elected by the American people.
Donald J. Trump was the 45th president. He, too, was not elected by the American people.
Rather, they were elected by electors.
In a letter to John Adams, Thomas Jefferson gushed over his vision of a “natural aristocracy” for the new nation. He believed the U.S. could have a new and improved aristocracy, one that values the best virtues, including work ethic, wisdom and discernment. These aristocrats that Jefferson envisioned would be the educated, virtuous elites of American society, defending the naive public from themselves.
This was part of the cultural moment that inspired the electoral college we have today: an elite group of aristocrats meant to protect the general public from voting foolishly.
Unsurprisingly, the American people have repeatedly found that concept unappealing. For one, in its original design, the electors were granted the power to completely override the will of their state’s people. Secondly, the electoral college requires the American public to openly admit that they are incapable of rightfully discerning who the next president should be, a severe hit to the American people’s egos.
Consequently, the electoral college has drastically evolved away from its original intention. The Supreme Court’s 2020 decision in Chiafalo v. Washington affirmed that states are at liberty to enforce elector pledges as well as penalize or replace faithless electors, those who vote against the results of a state’s election.
According to the Oregon Legislature website, as of January, 24 states as well as the District of Columbia have “strong” faithless elector laws, automatically replacing an elector who votes contrary to their pledge. According to the National Conference of State Legislatures, Virginia requires their electors to “vote as pledged,” forcing them to vote according to whom Virginians voted for. Additionally, both Maine and Nebraska uniquely award electoral votes by district — an attempt at proportionally respecting the will of the people.
Yet, despite Americans’ aversion to the original electoral college, and the many laws that states have since enshrined to circumnavigate it, we still find ourselves every four years, on a cold November night, refreshing our phones to see the big 270 flash over our screens.
According to South Dakota State Rep. Tina Mulally, (R-35), the electoral college is necessary in order to fairly balance rural and urban needs. Likewise, U.S. Sen. Bill Hagerty, (R-Tenn.) explained in a Fox News editorial that the electoral college must be maintained in order to ensure states like Tennessee can have their voice in presidential elections.
What Hagerty has missed, as do many supporters of the electoral college, is that Tennessee does not need a voice. The people of Tennessee do.
The electoral college undercuts the ability for third-party candidates to gain momentum.
It discourages, if not silences voters of the minority party in a state.
In many states, the system still allows electors to vote against the people’s wishes.
It concentrates campaigning efforts in swing states, according to NPR.
Most importantly, it results in presidents that never won over the majority of people’s wishes.
For far too long, the electoral college has been an outdated relic of a different time: undemocratic in its construction, unjust and unpopular in its execution. While many champion the rural and small state needs, it comes at the cost of the will of the individual.
Despite being established in our Constitution, a ticket out of the electoral college’s grip is on the table: The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact.
The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact gained momentum after the 2000 and 2016 presidential election results. The compact is an agreement between states to award their state’s electoral votes to the national popular vote winner, an agreement that has already been signed by 18 states and the District of Columbia. Gov. Abigail Spanberger signed Virginia into the agreement in April, according to ABC News.
The agreement is intended to have legal force once 270 electoral votes take part. Until then, the electoral college continues to maintain its place as our presidential election system. Post-midterm elections, the opportunity for new leadership to sign the compact presents itself, thus the question emerges again: Will our state legislators decide to protect the will of the people?
